👁️ 569 Blind Tasting
J
Jim
Reviewed Bottle
🥃
Whistle Pig 10 Year
WhistlePig Distillery
45.50% ABV
5.5/10
Overall Rating
Unknown
Tasting Environment
Tasting Notes
👁️ Appearance
Very light. Would guess either very young or a scotch based on color alone.
👃 Nose
Light nose. Slightly tropical. A little funky. A little cherry.
👅 Palate
Oak up front. A little spicy. Not much else. Slight mint. Low proof.
🏁 Finish
Lingering spice and oak.
👁️ Blind Tasting Impressions
I think it's a young rye, but I can't think of any that I have that would match. Not bad, but nothing special.
🎭 Post-Reveal Thoughts (Revealed Jan 07, 2026)
Correct on rye, wrong on young - but given it's a Canadian rye I'll take it. Hit the proof nearly right on. I gave the same rating in my last blind review in May 2025.
🎯 Pour Guess Results 0/40 (0%)
Guesses vs Reality
Type:
Rye Whiskey
✗
Proof:
90.0
Unknown
Age:
4yr
✗
10yr
Finished:
No
✗
Yes
Summary
Confidence Level:
Low
Total Score:
0/40
Accuracy:
0%
Secondary Grain: Corn
Community Discussion
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!
Review Details
Type:
Blind Tasting
Rating:
5.5/10
Would Recommend:
Yes
Would Buy Again:
No
Engagement
❤️ Likes
0
💬 Comments
0